top of page
Commercial Litigation


How Much Can A Subcontractor Collect on Its Mechanics’ Lien?
Mechanics’ liens are powerful tools available to, inter alia, contractors, laborers, and materialmen when they are not paid for their work in improving real property.

Jonathan Freiberger
7 hours ago5 min read


Fraud Allegations Dismissed Due To Bankruptcy Non-Disclosure
In Rubin v. Hodes, the Appellate Division, Second Department, affirmed the dismissal of fraud and loan repayment claims brought by a former majority shareholder of a healthcare company. However, the courts never reached the merits of those claims because the plaintiff failed to disclose his stock interests and promissory notes in a prior bankruptcy proceeding.

Jeffrey Haber
4 days ago6 min read


When Fraud Is Not Redundant: The Intersection of Merger Clauses and Duplicative Claims Doctrine
Merger clauses and the duplication of claims doctrine often operate to limit the availability of fraudulent inducement claims alongside breach of contract claims.

Jeffrey Haber
May 257 min read


It’s Settled – When to Settle an Order Pursuant to 22 NYCRR 202.48
When a court issues a decision and order that is self-effectuating, nothing further from the parties is required. Sometimes, however, a court’s decision will direct that the prevailing party either: (a) submit an order or judgment for the court to consider; or, (b) submit or settle an order or judgment, on notice, for the court’s consideration.

Jonathan Freiberger
May 224 min read


When “Some, All, or None” Means Something Different: Ambiguity in Contractual Duties and Compensation
Contract interpretation principles require courts to give effect to the parties’ intent as expressed in the plain language of their agreement, while reading the contract as a whole and avoiding constructions that render provisions meaningless.

Jeffrey Haber
May 207 min read


Breaking Ground or Breaking Promises: Dispute Over $1.075 Million Construction Claim
In today’s article, we examine Kingdom Assoc., Inc. v. WBC Servs. Inc., 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 03070 (1st Dept. May 14, 2026), a case arising from a proposed subcontract for excavation and foundation work on a New York City project.

Jeffrey Haber
May 184 min read


The Filing of a Settlement Conference RJI Insufficient -- This Time -- to Avoid Dismissal Under CPLR 3215(c)
CPLR 3215(c) mandates dismissal of a complaint as abandoned if a plaintiff fails to take proceedings for a default judgment within one year of a defendant’s default, unless “sufficient cause” (a reasonable excuse and potentially meritorious claim) is shown. Recent cases clarify what qualifies as “taking proceedings.”

Jonathan Freiberger
May 154 min read


Mechanics’ Liens and Discharge Bonds
Mechanics’ liens are powerful tools available to, inter alia, contractors, laborers and materialmen when they are not paid for their work in improving real property.

Jonathan Freiberger
May 85 min read


Disclosure as Defense: When Written Offering Materials Negate Claims of Fraudulent Misrepresentation
In Cortlandt St. Recovery Corp. v. TPG Capital Mgt., L.P., 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 02775 (1st Dept. May 5, 2026), the Appellate Division, First Department, examined the limits of fraud claims arising from complex private‑equity financing transactions.

Jeffrey Haber
May 66 min read


Conclusory Claims Fall Short: Second Department Dismisses Fraud and GBL § 349 Claims Against Insurance Adjuster
Conclusory allegations, even when bolstered by informal communications, such as text messages, will not substitute for well-pleaded facts showing materially misleading conduct or a specific misrepresentation.

Jeffrey Haber
May 35 min read


CPLR 322(a) Permits a Defendant to Demand Proof of Plaintiff’s Counsel’s Authority to Commence an Action Affecting Title to Real Property
CPLR 322(a) permits a defendant in an action affecting title to real property to demand proof that the plaintiff’s counsel was authorized to commence the action.

Jonathan Freiberger
May 14 min read


Foreign Banks, Foreign Disputes, and New York Courts: The Limits of Pre‑Judgment Attachment
Letters of credit are designed to reduce risk in international trade by reallocating who bears the risk of nonpayment, and when. Instead of relying solely on a buyer’s willingness or ability to pay, the seller relies on the issuing bank’s independent obligation.

Jeffrey Haber
Apr 2910 min read


Sometimes a Contract is Ambiguous, and Sometimes it is Not
Contracts are intended to bring certainty and clarity to commercial relationships, yet disputes often arise when written terms leave room for more than one reasonable interpretation. Under New York law, the question of ambiguity can determine whether a case is resolved on the face of the agreement or proceeds into litigation over extrinsic evidence and party intent.

Jeffrey Haber
Apr 278 min read


First Department Holds Mortgagor That Sold Property During Foreclosure Has Standing to Raise RPAPL 1304 Defense Because He May Be Liable For Deficiency
RPAPL 1304 requires that at least ninety days before commencing legal action against a borrower with respect to a “home loan” (as defined in the relevant statutes), a lender must: send written notice to the borrower by certified and regular mail that the loan is in default; provide a list of approved housing agencies that offer free or low-cost counseling; and, advise that legal action may be commenced after ninety days if no action is taken to resolve the matter.

Jonathan Freiberger
Apr 245 min read


When Fraud Isn’t Duplicative of Breach of Contract
Under New York law, fraud claims are not duplicative of breach of contract claims when they are based on misrepresentations of present fact collateral to the contract, even if they seek the same damages. Applying that rule, the Appellate Division, First Department held in Metropolitan Partners Group Admin., LLC v. Nerney, 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 02340 (1st Dept. Apr. 16, 2026), that plaintiff adequately pleaded both fraud and breach of contract claims ...

Jeffrey Haber
Apr 207 min read


The Equity of Redemption
In New York, the equity of redemption is a long standing common law right that allows those with certain interests in real property to redeem mortgaged property and prevent a foreclosure sale by tendering the full amount due at any time before the foreclosure sale.

Jonathan Freiberger
Apr 174 min read


Agreements to Agree Are Not Enforceable Contracts
In Kassirer v. Gotlib, 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 02154 (1st Dept. Apr. 9, 2026), the Appellate Division, First Department, reaffirmed a bedrock principle of New York contract law: agreements to agree are not enforceable.

Jeffrey Haber
Apr 136 min read


Sophisticated Parties, Precise Pleading, Fraud, and the Limits of NDAs in Transactions
Courts will dismiss breach of contract claims based on nondisclosure agreements where the plaintiff fails to identify specific confidential information allegedly misused. And fraud claims fail as a matter of law when a sophisticated party relies on oral assurances contradicted by written disclosures.

Jeffrey Haber
Apr 810 min read


For Whom the Interest Tolls
In prior BLOG articles, we discussed the court’s power to toll the accrual of interest in mortgage foreclosure actions.

Jonathan Freiberger
Apr 34 min read


The Duty of Good Faith and Fair Dealing
By: Jonathan H. Freiberger A basic tenet of contract interpretation is that “agreements are construed in accord with the parties’ intent.” Greenfield v. Philles Records, Inc. , 98 N.Y.2d 562, 569 (2002) (citations omitted); see also SM Owner, LLC v. Envoy Towers Co., L.P. , 245 A.D.3d 973 (2 nd Dept. 2026). It is equally fundamental that the “best evidence of what parties to a written agreement intend is what they say in their writing.” Greenfield , 98 N.Y.2d at 569 ( quotin

Jonathan Freiberger
Mar 274 min read
bottom of page
