top of page


Mistake, Memory, and Misunderstanding: Why the Release Still Stood
In Benowski v. Track Dr., LLC affirmed summary judgment dismissing a contractor’s claim for unpaid retainage and other compensation arising from a commercial renovation project. Although the parties never executed a formal written construction contract, the Court enforced a January 2020 release under which the contractor acknowledged that $233,797.23 constituted the “entire unpaid balance” due and waived all claims relating to the project.

Jeffrey Haber
7d7 min read


Breaking Ground or Breaking Promises: Dispute Over $1.075 Million Construction Claim
In today’s article, we examine Kingdom Assoc., Inc. v. WBC Servs. Inc., 2026 N.Y. Slip Op. 03070 (1st Dept. May 14, 2026), a case arising from a proposed subcontract for excavation and foundation work on a New York City project.

Jeffrey Haber
May 184 min read


Summary Judgment Sought Even Though Summary Judgment in Lieu of Complaint at Plaintiff’s Disposal
New York’s CPLR 3213 allows a plaintiff to seek summary judgment in lieu of a complaint when liability for a sum certain is evident from an instrument for the payment of money only, such as a promissory note or unconditional guaranty. This expedited procedure avoids delays inherent in filing and answering a complaint.

Jeffrey Haber
Dec 31, 20256 min read


It’s The Terms of the Contract That Control
In any contract dispute, “it is necessary to consider the language in the contract, for that is what controls the parties’ rights and responsibilities.” For this reason, New York courts “are guided by the standard rules of contractual interpretation, which provide that ‘a written agreement that is complete, clear and unambiguous on its face must be enforced according to the plain meaning of its terms.’”

Jeffrey Haber
Dec 15, 20259 min read


Proposed Amendment to Prayer for Relief Based on Unrealized Profits Incurred as a Result of Alleged Fraud Violates the Out-Of-Pocket Damages Rule
In Sire Spirits, LLC v. Beam Suntory, Inc., 2025 N.Y. Slip Op. 06297 (1st Dept. Nov. 18, 2025), the Appellate Division, First Department affirmed the denial of a motion to amend a complaint seeking damages for “diminution of enterprise value” due to the alleged fraud.

Jeffrey Haber
Nov 19, 20258 min read


“Variety is the Spice of Life” -- Service of Process under CPLR 308(4)
Obtaining personal jurisdiction[1] over a defendant is a critical aspect of litigation.

Jonathan Freiberger
Nov 7, 20257 min read


Business Dispute Between Sisters Dismissed on Statute of Limitations Grounds
In New York, as in most jurisdictions, statutes of limitation serve as a cutoff point for initiating legal action. In business litigation, parties often encounter statutes of limitation issues involving, inter alia, breach of fiduciary duty and fraud claims.

Jeffrey Haber
Sep 15, 20258 min read


Consequential Damages: Are They Foreseeable?
In today’s article, we examine BLDG 44 Developers LLC v. Pace Companies N.Y., LLC, a case involving consequential damages.

Jeffrey Haber
Aug 27, 20257 min read


The Relation Back Doctrine and Statutes of Limitation in Mortgage Foreclosure Actions
Today’s BLOG deals with the “Relation Back Doctrine” (the “Doctrine”), which, inter alia, “allows a claim asserted against a defendant in an amended filing to relate back to claims previously asserted against a codefendant for Statute of Limitations purposes where the two defendants are “‘united in interest.’"”

Jonathan Freiberger
Aug 1, 20255 min read


Second Department Holds that Relief Under CPLR 3213 was Unavailable for Claim Under Guaranty of Lease
Today’s article relates to summary judgment in lieu of complaint pursuant to CPLR 3213

Jonathan Freiberger
Jul 11, 20254 min read


Fraudulent Inducement and The Independent Contractor Agreement
In Wilburger v. Ava Labs, Inc., 2025 N.Y. Slip Op. 51072(U) (Sup. Ct., N.Y. County July 3, 2025) (here), plaintiff sued defendant for breach of contract, unjust enrichment, and fraudulent inducement related to unpaid compensation for services rendered under an Independent Contractor Agreement.

Jeffrey Haber
Jul 9, 20259 min read


Fraud and Fraudulent Transfer Counterclaims Against Corporate Individuals Survive Motion to Dismiss, Says The First Department
In One River Run Acquisition, LLC v. Milde, 2025 N.Y. Slip Op. 03653 (1st Dept. June 17, 2025) (here), the Appellate Division, First Department reinstated counterclaims for fraud and fraudulent transfers after they had been dismissed at the motion court level.

Jeffrey Haber
Jun 18, 20256 min read


Second Department Holds that Defendant Waived Right to Vacate a Foreclosure Sale Not Held Within 90 Days of Judgment of Foreclosure and Sale
In today’s Blog, we revisit the requirement in RPAPL 1351(1) that a foreclosure sale occur within 90 days of the date of the judgment of foreclosure and sale.

Jonathan Freiberger
May 30, 20254 min read


Charter-Time Warner Merger Sparks Univision Licensing Fee Dispute
By: Jeffrey M. Haber After a merger, which agreement controls when both companies have pre-existing contracts with a common third party? In May 2016, Stamford-based Charter Communications Inc. (“Charter”) completed its acquisition of Time Warner Cable (“TWC”), making it the second largest cable provider behind Comcast Corporation. At the time of the acquisition, TWC was the larger of the two companies. As such, TWC was able to negotiate more favorable rates and terms on ca

Jeffrey Haber
Jul 20, 20162 min read


It Takes Energy to Circumvent an Alternative Dispute Resolution Agreement
By: Jeffrey M. Haber Is it a breach of contract to bypass an agreed-upon, independent alternative dispute resolution (“ADR”) process and commence an arbitration proceeding elsewhere? When two companies enter into a contract, it’s common to include language wherein both parties consent to having any disputes related to the contract decided by an agreed-upon, neutral third party, rather than by a judge in a lengthy, formal court proceeding. The process of ADR-- which may be by

Jeffrey Haber
Jun 27, 20162 min read
bottom of page
