top of page
Business Litigation
Obtaining A Prejudgment Attachment Order Is Not Easy, Even Where Fraud Is Alleged
Prejudgment attachment is a provisional remedy that provides a plaintiff with a statutory mechanism by which he/she can secure a defendant’s assets during the pendency of a lawsuit. In effect, an order of attachment is a lien against a defendant’s property. As such, a prejudgment order of attachment increases the likelihood of recovery on a later-obtained judgment in the action. The requirements for obtaining a prejudgment attachment order vary from state to state; there is
admin
Jul 28, 20177 min read
Court Rules That The Failure To Read An Insurance Policy Does Not Bar A Claim For Failure To Obtain Insurance
No one likes to read fine print or lengthy agreements. Anyone buying insurance, for example, knows this to be so. In fact, a 2016 car insurance TV commercial by Liberty Mutual highlights this point. In the ad, the actress talks about an insurance policy that is over 20 pages long that no one reads, except for lawyers. The question becomes, then, does a failure to read an insurance policy bar a claim against an insurance company or broker for failing to obtain insurance believ
admin
Jul 26, 20174 min read
Plaintiffs Can Go Forum Shopping After All
Earlier this month, Judge Richard J. Sullivan of the Southern District of New York dismissed a federal claim at the plaintiffs’ request, despite the defendants’ argument that the plaintiffs were “clearly and intentionally attempting to engage in forum manipulation.” In Nix v. Office of The Commissioner of Baseball, D/B/A Major League Baseball , Judge Sullivan found that while the plaintiffs’ “manifest purpose” was “to defeat federal jurisdiction” it was not the only factor t
admin
Jul 24, 20174 min read
Corporate Veil Pierced Due To Fraud On Creditor
Although courts will pierce the corporate veil “to prevent fraud or achieve equity,” Morris v. N.Y. State Department of Taxation & Finance , 82 N.Y.2d 135, 140 (1993) (quoting Int’l Aircraft Trading Co. v. Mfrs. Trust Co. , 297 N.Y. 285, 292 (1948)), they are, nevertheless, reluctant to disregard the corporate form. TNS Holdings Inc. v. MKI Sec. Corp. , 92 N.Y.2d 335, 339 (1998). After all, the purpose of incorporating is to allow individuals to avoid personal liability. See
admin
Jul 20, 201711 min read
Judge Approves Settlement in Wells Fargo Accounts Scandal
A federal judge has given Well Fargo & Co. preliminary approval of its proposed $142 million class-action settlement to compensate millions of customers swept up in the fake account scandal that led to the ouster of CEO John Stumpf in October 2016. Current Wells Fargo Chief Executive Tim Sloan said in a statement that the proposed settlement represents "a major milestone in our efforts to make things right for our customers." The Wells Fargo Scandal The scandal broke in 201
admin
Jul 19, 20172 min read
Heightened Pleading Standard For Tortious Interference With Contract Too Difficult to Overcome For Aggrieved Company
Since the early 1900s, tortious interference with contractual relations has been a viable cause of action in New York. E.g. , S.C. Posner Co. v. Jackson , 223 N.Y. 325, 332 (1918); Lamb v. Cheney & Son , 227 N.Y. 418, 421 (1920). It occurs when a business or individual who is not a party to a contract intentionally disrupts a business relationship formed by a contract. Lama Holding v. Smith Barney , 88 N.Y.2d 413, 424 (1996). Under New York law, an action for interference w
admin
Jun 21, 20174 min read
35 Second Excerpt From Jazz Album Found To Be Fair Use By Rapper
Jimmy Smith is widely considered to have been one of the most influential and accomplished jazz musicians of his time, if not in jazz history. Smith, who died in 2005, revolutionized the use of the Hammond B3 organ in modern jazz, laying the groundwork for generations of jazz musicians to come. Estate of James Oscar Smith v. Cash Money Records, Inc. In 2013, rapper/singer/songwriter Drake released Pound Cake/Paris Morton Music 2 (“Pound Cake”) on his album, Nothing Was the
admin
Jun 19, 20176 min read
Email Correspondence Concerning The Sale Of Real Estate Not Enough To Satisfy The Statute Of Frauds
The New York Statute of Frauds provides that “ contract for the . . . the sale, of any real property, or an interest therein, is void unless the contract or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing, subscribed by the party to be charged, or by his lawful agent thereunto authorized by writing.” New York General Obligations Law § 5-703(2). “To satisfy the statue of frauds, a memorandum evidencing a contract and subscribed by the party to be
admin
Jun 16, 20174 min read
Piercing The Corporate Veil: Business Owner Found Jointly And Severally Liable For The Company’s Fraudulent Acts
This Blog has previously written about the benefits of forming a limited liability corporation (“LLC”) and the perils of ignoring the corporate formalities that are attendant thereto. ( Here .) In today’s post, this Blog will examine the use of the corporate entity to commit a fraud on another and a court’s willingness to pierce the corporate veil to hold the owners or members personally liable for that wrongful conduct. When to Pierce the Corporate Veil: In general, the cour
admin
May 22, 20175 min read
Former Baseball Player Learns That An Agreement By Email Is Enforceable
Since his retirement, former Mets and Phillies outfielder, Lenny Dykstra (“Dykstra”), has been involved in many civil and criminal proceedings. Recently, for example, Dykstra was sued by Noah Scheinmann (“Scheinmann”), the former ballplayer’s social media ghost writer, for breaching a contract in which Dykstra hired Scheinmann to create a social media presence to promote Dykstra’s book, “House of Nails: A Memoir of Life on the Edge.” According to the complaint ( here ), Sche
admin
May 19, 20174 min read
Does An Agreement Really Have To Be In Writing?
Attorneys are often asked whether an oral agreement is enforceable. Most will say that the answer depends on the law and the facts surrounding the agreement. As an initial matter, to be enforceable, an oral agreement must contain the elements of a binding contract, e.g. , an offer, acceptance, consideration, mutual assent, an intent to be bound, and agreement on all essential terms. (This Blog wrote about these elements here and here .) Even if these elements are present, t
admin
May 17, 20175 min read
Court Upholds Striking Answer As Sanction For Failure To Comply With Discovery Demands And Discovery Orders
Litigants and their attorneys who fail to comply with discovery demands and/or discovery orders do so at their peril. Such non-compliance can lead to penalties and sanctions, especially when the non-compliance arises from deliberate behavior. When a party deliberately fails to comply with discovery demands and/or discovery orders, the requesting party may file a motion to compel compliance pursuant to Section 3124 of the Civil Practice Rules and Procedure (“CPLR”) or a motio
admin
Apr 26, 20174 min read
Fraud Action Dismissed On Standing Grounds Because The Claim Did Not Transfer With The Assignment Of The Contract
Last year, this Blog wrote about the importance of assigning title to, or ownership in, a claim, when assigning the right to pursue an action to another party. ( Here .) Recently, the issue arose in connection with an action alleging, among other things, fraud and negligent misrepresentation in connection with the purchase and sale of residential mortgage-backed securities (“RMBS”). On April 12, 2017, in Royal Park Investments SA/NV v. Morgan Stanley ( here ), Justice Charl
admin
Apr 24, 20173 min read
A Lesson In Personal Liability For Owners Of A Soon-To-Be Formed Llc
The limited liability company (“LLC”) is a relatively new business form that combines features of a corporation (a separate legal entity and limited liability) and those of a partnership (pass-through taxation and contractual flexibility). This Blog previously wrote about the advantages and disadvantages of this business structure. ( Here .) In the past several years, the LLC has become the business structure of choice for entrepreneurs and small business owners. Unfortunate
admin
Apr 19, 20174 min read
Another Faithless Servant Required to Forfeit Compensation
Last November, this Blog discussed the faithless servant doctrine under New York law. ( Here .) As explained, the courts have applied the doctrine to a wide variety of misconduct, including, but not limited to, conflicts of interest, stealing money or goods, and secretly starting a competing business. Any act that can give rise to a claim for breach of fiduciary duty will trigger the doctrine. The penalty for violating the doctrine is harsh: the employee must forfeit all com
admin
Mar 16, 20174 min read
Spoliation Of Evidence, Even If Done In The Normal Course Of Business, Is Sanctionable
An important part of any litigation is documentary discovery. As any litigant can attest, especially in complex matters, documents form the foundation of discovery plans and strategies, and, more significantly, proof at trial. Consequently, litigants must collect and preserve their documents, particularly electronically stored information (“ESI”), from the moment they are aware of their involvement in a lawsuit, or when there is a reasonable anticipation that a lawsuit may be
admin
Mar 8, 20176 min read
Confirmation Of Deal With After-The-Fact Terms And Conditions Is Part Of The Original Agreement
Your client is engaged in negotiations to sell his company’s widgets in a purchase and sale transaction. After months of negotiations, the parties verbally agree to the salient terms of the transaction – that is, they agree to price, quantity, and specifications. You summarize these terms in an email on the same day. Your email also confirms that a formal contract will follow. The following day, you send the contract to the buyer and its counsel. The agreement contains the a
admin
Mar 6, 20175 min read
Llc Breakups And Judicial Dissolution: The Hurdles Are High
Over the past few weeks, this Blog has explored the advantages and disadvantages of forming a limited liability company (“LLC”), as well as the fiduciary obligations of non-managing members in manager-managed LLC to each other and the LLC itself ( here and here ). In today’s installment, this Blog will explore the circumstances under which a member in a multi-member LLC can obtain a judicial dissolution of the company. The Law Governing the Dissolution of an LLC An LLC i
admin
Mar 3, 20179 min read
When a Term Sheet is Not an Enforceable Contract
Last month, this Blog wrote about McGowan v. Clarion Partners, LLC , a decision involving the enforceability of a transaction term sheet. In McGowan , Justice Scarpulla of the New York County, Supreme Court, Commercial Division, held that the term sheet before the court was a binding contract because it contained all the material terms of the proposed venture that would reasonably have been expected to be included under the circumstances. This month, by contrast, Justice Sin
admin
Feb 22, 20176 min read
President Trump Issues Directive to Roll Back Dodd-Frank Act
On the same day that he signed a directive ordering a review of the Labor Department's fiduciary rule (discussed here ), President Trump signed an executive order directing the Treasury Secretary and other regulators to review existing regulations to determine whether they support six core principles. Included in those principles are: Empowering Americans to make independent financial decisions; Fostering economic growth through more rigorous regulatory impact analysis; Advan
admin
Feb 20, 20172 min read
bottom of page
