top of page
Commercial Litigation
Fraud Action Dismissed On Standing Grounds Because The Claim Did Not Transfer With The Assignment Of The Contract
Last year, this Blog wrote about the importance of assigning title to, or ownership in, a claim, when assigning the right to pursue an action to another party. ( Here .) Recently, the issue arose in connection with an action alleging, among other things, fraud and negligent misrepresentation in connection with the purchase and sale of residential mortgage-backed securities (“RMBS”). On April 12, 2017, in Royal Park Investments SA/NV v. Morgan Stanley ( here ), Justice Charl
admin
Apr 24, 20173 min read
A Lesson In Personal Liability For Owners Of A Soon-To-Be Formed Llc
The limited liability company (“LLC”) is a relatively new business form that combines features of a corporation (a separate legal entity and limited liability) and those of a partnership (pass-through taxation and contractual flexibility). This Blog previously wrote about the advantages and disadvantages of this business structure. ( Here .) In the past several years, the LLC has become the business structure of choice for entrepreneurs and small business owners. Unfortunate
admin
Apr 19, 20174 min read
Another Faithless Servant Required to Forfeit Compensation
Last November, this Blog discussed the faithless servant doctrine under New York law. ( Here .) As explained, the courts have applied the doctrine to a wide variety of misconduct, including, but not limited to, conflicts of interest, stealing money or goods, and secretly starting a competing business. Any act that can give rise to a claim for breach of fiduciary duty will trigger the doctrine. The penalty for violating the doctrine is harsh: the employee must forfeit all com
admin
Mar 16, 20174 min read
Spoliation Of Evidence, Even If Done In The Normal Course Of Business, Is Sanctionable
An important part of any litigation is documentary discovery. As any litigant can attest, especially in complex matters, documents form the foundation of discovery plans and strategies, and, more significantly, proof at trial. Consequently, litigants must collect and preserve their documents, particularly electronically stored information (“ESI”), from the moment they are aware of their involvement in a lawsuit, or when there is a reasonable anticipation that a lawsuit may be
admin
Mar 8, 20176 min read
Confirmation Of Deal With After-The-Fact Terms And Conditions Is Part Of The Original Agreement
Your client is engaged in negotiations to sell his company’s widgets in a purchase and sale transaction. After months of negotiations, the parties verbally agree to the salient terms of the transaction – that is, they agree to price, quantity, and specifications. You summarize these terms in an email on the same day. Your email also confirms that a formal contract will follow. The following day, you send the contract to the buyer and its counsel. The agreement contains the a
admin
Mar 6, 20175 min read
Llc Breakups And Judicial Dissolution: The Hurdles Are High
Over the past few weeks, this Blog has explored the advantages and disadvantages of forming a limited liability company (“LLC”), as well as the fiduciary obligations of non-managing members in manager-managed LLC to each other and the LLC itself ( here and here ). In today’s installment, this Blog will explore the circumstances under which a member in a multi-member LLC can obtain a judicial dissolution of the company. The Law Governing the Dissolution of an LLC An LLC i
admin
Mar 3, 20179 min read
FINRA Targeting Rogue Brokers
Last month this blog wrote about the Securities and Exchange Commission's list of exam priorities for 2017 here . Included in that list was a focus on registered representatives and employers with prior records of misconduct. This is also an exam priority for the Financial Institution's Regulatory Authority (Finra). The self regulatory organization has put in place a new exam unit that will focus on identifying high risk and recidivist brokers who pose a potential risk to in
admin
Feb 24, 20172 min read
When a Term Sheet is Not an Enforceable Contract
Last month, this Blog wrote about McGowan v. Clarion Partners, LLC , a decision involving the enforceability of a transaction term sheet. In McGowan , Justice Scarpulla of the New York County, Supreme Court, Commercial Division, held that the term sheet before the court was a binding contract because it contained all the material terms of the proposed venture that would reasonably have been expected to be included under the circumstances. This month, by contrast, Justice Sin
admin
Feb 22, 20176 min read
President Trump Issues Directive to Roll Back Dodd-Frank Act
On the same day that he signed a directive ordering a review of the Labor Department's fiduciary rule (discussed here ), President Trump signed an executive order directing the Treasury Secretary and other regulators to review existing regulations to determine whether they support six core principles. Included in those principles are: Empowering Americans to make independent financial decisions; Fostering economic growth through more rigorous regulatory impact analysis; Advan
admin
Feb 20, 20172 min read
Court Issues Injunction Enforcing A Covenant Not To Compete In Connection With The Sale Of A Business
The enforceability of a covenant not to compete is an issue that commercial and business lawyers often consider in their practice. Sometimes, the issue arises when an employee leaves a business to open his/her own shop, while other times the issue arises in the sale of a company. On January 18, 2017, in Shimon v. Paper Enterprises, Inc. , 2017 NY Slip Op. 30101(U) , Justice Sylvia G. Ash of the Supreme Court, Kings County, Commercial Division, issued an injunction enforcing
admin
Feb 8, 20175 min read
A Transaction Term Sheet Can Be A Valid And Enforceable Contract
Parties to commercial/business transactions are no doubt familiar with “term sheets”, “letters of intent”, “memoranda of understanding” and “agreements in principle”. As the parties to these documents know, they outline the fundamental terms of the transaction being negotiated. Terms sheets and the like have a number of advantages: they can be drafted without the expense of hiring a lawyer; they reduce later renegotiation and lapses in memory; they can facilitate discussions
admin
Jan 26, 20177 min read
Business Owners Beware: Your Forum Selection Clause May Not Be Enforceable
What is a forum selection clause? Corporations and other business entities are all too familiar with them. In its simplest form, a forum selection clause is a provision in a contract that designates a specific location (or a particular court within a specific location) for litigation in the event of a dispute. Forum selection clauses are common in commercial contracts because they “provide certainty and predictability in the resolution of disputes.” Boss v. American Express
admin
Jan 17, 20174 min read
Only A Material Breach Of Contract Can Support A Party’s Non-Performance Or Claim For Rescission
A breach of contract comes in two primary varieties: a material breach and a minor breach. The former is substantial, goes to the very heart of the agreement and prevents the contract from being performed. When a material breach occurs, the non-breaching party can cease performing under the agreement and sue to collect the damages caused by the breach. The latter, also known as a partial breach, occurs when a party fails to complete a less important part of a contract. Impo
admin
Jan 13, 20178 min read
Arbitration Agreements May Not Be Enforceable Even When They Are Clear And Unambiguous
Business owners hate litigation. In fact, there are few things they hate more. Litigation damages relationships, tarnishes reputations, and interferes with business operations. Even small claims divert time, money and talent. So, how can corporations and small businesses avoid these costs and expenses? The answer: alternative dispute resolution, such as arbitration and mediation. Over the past few decades, it has become commonplace for corporations and small businesses to i
admin
Jan 10, 20175 min read
It Seems You Can’t Waive The Affirmative Defense Of Illegality After All
Your client comes to you with a complaint that was recently served on him. Among other claims, the plaintiff contends that your client breached his agreement to sell widgets. After discussing the claims with your client, you decide to file an answer. Your analysis of the contract claim leads you to conclude that the contract is void because performance would require your client to violate certain labor laws. In addition to general denials, you assert several affirmative defe
admin
Jan 6, 20174 min read
KNET, INC. V. RUOCCO: Issuing Stock For Inadequate Consideration
From time to time, this Blog has written about lawsuits involving corporations, including those brought as shareholder derivative actions ( here ). As this Blog explained, a derivative action is a lawsuit brought by a shareholder of a company, on behalf, and for the benefit, of the company to enforce or defend a legal right or claim. Derivative actions seek the recovery of damages and/or equitable relief arising from unlawful or improper conduct engaged in by officers, direct
admin
Jan 5, 20177 min read
New York attorney general to introduce legislation aimed at curbing misuse of non-compete agreements
What could this legislation mean for New York businesses? New York Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman recently introduced legislation intended to reduce the use of non-compete agreements in the workplace. The bill is designed to protect the rights of workers to find better employment opportunities, particularly for low-wage earners who have been hindered in their ability to move to new jobs because of non-compete agreements. Schneiderman’s bill includes: A ban on all non
admin
Dec 30, 20162 min read
Who Needs A Formal Contract When An Offer, Acceptance And The Exchange Of Consideration Can Be Gleaned From The Totality Of The Parties’ Actions And Communications?
We live in a technologically advanced world. Our phones are smart, our tablets are mini-computers, and our laptops/notebooks are more powerful than ever. We can interact with each other through email, text messaging and other forms of electronic communications. Gone, for the most part, are the more formal, traditional ways of communicating with each other, e.g. , letters and faxes. As the modern ways of communicating have become the norm, many business executives and owner
admin
Dec 28, 20167 min read
Piercing The Corporate Veil: Who May Be At Risk?
Let’s say you, the reader, are an entrepreneur who wants to open a business. Although you are willing to run the risks associated with a startup, you do not want to incur any personal liability for the acts done by the business. After speaking with your family, friends and neighbors, you decide to incorporate the business. The consensus view is that a corporate entity, such as a corporation or limited liability corporation (“LLC”), will enable you to operate the business and
admin
Dec 14, 201610 min read
Founder of PureChoice on Trial for Federal Fraud Charges
Bryan Reichel, founder of PureChoice -- deceptive or duped? Business lawsuits involving accusations of fraud can be complicated and confusing. It is sometimes difficult to decipher who is lying and who is telling the truth. On the one hand, there is a successful CEO, who is alleged to have committed fraud to develop or maintain a lavish lifestyle. While, on the other hand, there is an accuser who stands to gain money and power by overthrowing the existing kingpin. If you fin
admin
Oct 20, 20163 min read
bottom of page
