top of page
All Posts
New York Court of Appeals Addresses Specific Jurisdiction, Holding That Defendant Purposefully Availed Itself of The Protections of New York Law
By: Jeffrey M. Haber On February 14, 2023, the New York Court of Appeals decided State of New York v. Vayu, Inc. , 2023 N.Y. Slip Op. 00801 (Feb. 14, 2023) ( here ). Vayu addressed what it means to purposefully avail oneself of the privilege of conducting activities within New York by transacting business in the state. In a 5-1 decision, authored by Judge Michael J. Garcia, the Court held that Vayu, acting through its chief executive officer, repeatedly projected itself into
admin
Feb 15, 202312 min read
Scrivener’s Error and Mutual Mistake
By: Jeffrey M. Haber As readers of this Blog know, to form a contract, the following elements must be present: an offer, acceptance of the offer, consideration, mutual assent (or a meeting of the minds) and an intent to be bound. Contracts are subject to the equitable remedy of rescission or reformation if entered under a mutual mistake. 1 To invoke the doctrine of mutual mistake, a party must present proof that the agreement, as expressed, does not represent a “meeting of t
admin
Feb 13, 20235 min read
Yellowstone Injunctions Have Nothing to Do With Kevin Costner’s Leases
By Jonathan H. Freiberger A commercial lease can be a valuable asset for a business. Accordingly, a tenant must be mindful of its rights in the face of a default/cure notice from a landlord. Generally, a tenant that wants to retain its lease and disputes a curable default, or cannot remedy a curable default within the contractual cure period, should consider obtaining a Yellowstone injunction. Yellowstone="<em>Yellowstone</em>" injunctions="injunctions" here,=">here</a>,"
admin
Feb 10, 20235 min read
Failure to Consider Theories Raised by Plaintiff in Prior Action Spells Denial of Dismissal of Second Action on Res Judicata Grounds
By: Jeffrey M. Haber Previously, this Blog has examined the doctrine of res judicata ( here and here ). Under the doctrine, a party may not litigate a claim where a judgment on the merits exists from a prior action between the same parties involving the same subject matter. The doctrine applies not only to claims actually litigated but also to claims that could have been raised in the prior litigation. The rationale underlying the doctrine is that a party who has been give
admin
Feb 8, 20235 min read
Enforcement News: Video Game Company Agrees to Pay $35 Million To Settle Charges Concerning Whistleblower Protection Rule and Maintenance of Adequate Disclosure Controls
By: Jeffrey M. Haber We have often written about the SEC’s whistleblower program and, in particular, the success of the program with respect to detecting and preventing violations of the federal securities laws. The success of the program depends, in large part, on the ability of would-be whistleblowers to have the freedom to report wrongdoing without fear of reprisal. Taking steps to impede a departing employee from sharing information with the SEC impairs this free flow of
admin
Feb 6, 20237 min read
If I Only Had a Stapler, We could Have Gotten Allonge Better
By Jonathan H. Freiberger This Blog frequently addresses issues related to mortgage foreclosure actions, generally, and issues of standing, specifically. Much of the background of this article was taken from a prior article: “ Appellate Division, Second Department, Validates Mortgage Foreclosure Defendants’ Cries of ‘Leave me Allonge ’”. As to the issues relating to the standing of a lender to commence a foreclosure action, this Blog has noted that, in general, a foreclosin
admin
Feb 3, 20234 min read
Breach of Contract: Repudiation and Abandonment
By Jeffrey M. Haber Under New York law, a party’s termination of a contract is ineffective when the contract provides for notice and an opportunity to cure, and notice was not provided. 1 As explained by the First Department: Our case law is clear that a party’s termination is ineffective where the relevant contract provides for a notice to cure and notice is not provided …This approach gives effect to the principle that, generally, where contracting parties agree on a term
admin
Feb 1, 20236 min read
When is a Term Sheet Binding? When the Parties Say So
By: Jeffrey M. Haber Parties to commercial transactions are no doubt familiar with “term sheets”, “letters of intent”, “memoranda of understanding” and “agreements in principle”. As the parties to these documents know, they outline the fundamental terms of the transaction being negotiated. “Term sheets”, “letters of intent”, “memoranda of understanding” and “agreements in principle” may constitute an enforceable agreement if the writing includes all the essential terms of an
admin
Jan 30, 20236 min read
Setting Aside a Judicial Sale
By Jonathan H. Freiberger Regular readers of this Blog know that we spend a good deal of time writing about mortgage foreclosure. The anticipated conclusion of a mortgage foreclosure action is a foreclosure sale. The judicial sale is also the hoped-for conclusion of other types of proceedings – such as mechanic’s lien foreclosures and condominium lien foreclosures. Once conducted, there are mechanisms to set aside judicial sales when warranted. “ ven after a judicial sale
admin
Jan 27, 20234 min read
“Wayward and Unruly Agent” Found To Forfeit All Compensation Under The Faithless Servant Doctrine
By: Jeffrey M. Haber The faithless servant doctrine 1 provides that an employee who is faithless in the performance of their duties ( i.e. , breaches their duty of loyalty to the employer) is not entitled to recover either salary or commission. 2 While the language of the rule may imply a broad application, courts generally apply the rule relatively narrowly. 3 Courts will usually hold an employee liable under the faithless servant doctrine only if the employee has usurped
admin
Jan 25, 20236 min read
Omission Case Dismissed Because Defendants Had No Duty to Disclose
By: Jeffrey M. Haber Typically, when a plaintiff claims to have been defrauded, he/she typically argues that the defendant made an affirmative misrepresentation of fact. Fraud does not, however, always concern an affirmative statement. Sometimes a person can perpetrate a fraud through the omission of a material fact. Where fraud by omission is claimed, the plaintiff must allege that the defendant had a duty to disclose the omitted fact. A duty to disclose arises when (1) the
admin
Jan 23, 20235 min read
Enforcement News: The Intersection of Affinity Fraud and a Ponzi Scheme
By: Jeffrey M. Haber In prior articles we have examined Ponzi Schemes and affinity fraud. E.g. , here . We do so again today. Affinity fraud occurs when the promoter of the fraud preys upon members of an identifiable group, such as a religious or ethnic community, the elderly, or a professional group. The promoter frequently is – or pretends to be – a member or a good friend of the group. The promoter often enlists respected members of the community or religious leaders from
admin
Jan 18, 20233 min read
Reliance on Emails Not Enough to Avoid Dismissal Under Statute of Frauds
By: Jeffrey M. Haber The statute of frauds provides that “ contract for the . . . the sale, of any real property, or an interest therein, is void unless the contract or some note or memorandum thereof, expressing the consideration, is in writing, subscribed by the party to be charged, or by his lawful agent thereunto authorized by writing.” 1 “To satisfy the statue of frauds, a memorandum evidencing a contract and subscribed by the party to be charged must designate the par
admin
Jan 17, 20235 min read
Appellate Division, First Department Shows Little Mercy for Litigant that Filed Untimely Summary Judgment Motion
By Jonathan H. Freiberger As the Court of Appeals has explained it, “ ummary judgment permits a party to show, by affidavit or other evidence, that there is no material issue of fact to be tried, and that judgment may be directed as a matter of law, thereby avoiding needless litigation cost and delay. Where appropriate, summary judgment is a great benefit both to the parties and to the overburdened New York State trial courts.” Brill v. City of New York , 2 N.Y.3d 648, 651 (
admin
Jan 13, 20234 min read
The Many Facets of a Fraudulent Inducement Claim
By: Jeffrey M. Haber We start the new year off examining Dragons 516 Ltd. v. Knights Genesis Inv. Ltd. , 2023 N.Y. Slip Op. 50020(U) (Sup. Ct., N.Y. County Jan. 6, 2023) ( here ), a case involving many of the themes we often consider in our discussion of fraud and fraudulent inducement claims. Dragons involved a dispute between a lender and a borrower. Plaintiff, Dragons 516 Limited (“Dragons”), alleged that defendants fraudulently conspired to misrepresent the ownership str
admin
Jan 11, 20238 min read
Enforcement News: SEC Files Suit in Connection with $45 Million “Too Good To Be True” Scheme to Defraud
By: Jeffrey M. Haber In promoting a scam, fraud operators expect investors will jump at the opportunity to obtain a life-changing financial reward from their investment, especially if the investment opportunity does not require a large outlay of money. For this reason, many investment frauds involve false promises of extraordinary payouts with minimal risk. Unfortunately, too many investors are lulled into believing these promises and give their hard-earned money to these fra
admin
Jan 9, 20232 min read
Defendants’ In-Person Activities in New York Sufficient to Support the Exercise of Specific Personal Jurisdiction
By: Jeffrey M. Haber Obtaining jurisdiction over a person or corporation that is domiciled outside of the state can be difficult. A plaintiff must plead and prove that the person or entity purposefully used the resources of the state for a court to exercise personal jurisdiction over the defendant. The failure to do so will result in dismissal of the action. Under CPLR § 302(a)(1), a court can exercise specific personal jurisdiction over a non-domiciliary who “transacts any
admin
Jan 6, 20236 min read
Enforcement News: SEC Charges Financial Services Professional and Associate with Perpetrating a Front-Running Scheme
By: Jeffrey M. Haber “Front-running” involves trading ahead of large, nonpublic orders of market participants to benefit from the market impact of those large orders. Large orders can have an impact on the price of a security when they cause an imbalance in the supply or demand for that security, thereby causing the price of that security to increase or decrease. Front-running was the focus of an enforcement action that the Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) brought
admin
Dec 28, 20222 min read
bottom of page
