top of page
All Posts
Dismissal of Securities Fraud Claim in Federal Court Has No Preclusive Effect on Common Law Fraud Claims Brought in State Court
Dismissal of Securities Fraud Claim in Federal Court Has No Preclusive Effect on Common Law Fraud Claims Brought in State Court Securities fraud and common law fraud have much in common. The core elements required to prevail on both claims are similar. Yet, dismissal of a federal securities fraud claim is not necessarily the death knell of a common law fraud claim. Recently, Justice O. Peter Sherwood of the Supreme Court, New York County, Commercial Division, reached this co
admin
Nov 14, 20189 min read
Court Holds Corporate Officers Personally Liable for Participation in An Alleged Conversion of Assets
< editor's note: this article has been edited. > editor's note: this article has been edited.> As discussed in previous Blog posts ( here and here ), business owners and entrepreneurs wishing to insulate themselves from personal liability for the acts taken in the name of their business can generally do so by forming a corporation ( e.g. , C-Corp. or an S-Corp.) or limited liability company (“LLC”). Such protection, however, is not absolute; there are exceptions to the rule
admin
Nov 12, 20185 min read
First Department Holds Compliance with No-Action Clause in Indenture Was Excused on Futility Grounds
Practitioners and their clients involved in bond offerings or other credit instruments are no strangers to trust indentures. These agreements typically contain a no-action clause, the primary purpose of which is to deter minority securityholders from filing duplicative, economically inefficient, or otherwise meritless lawsuits against the issuer, servicer, or other third party at the expense of the majority’s interest. No-action clauses generally achieve these purposes by fu
admin
Nov 7, 20186 min read
Court Holds that Motion to Compel Arbitration Cannot be Made Until the Non-Movant Initiates Litigation
Arbitration is an alternative form of dispute resolution where the parties voluntarily agree that a neutral, private person will resolve any legal disputes between them, instead of a judge or jury in a court of law. In recent years, arbitration has increased in popularity and is part of most business and commercial contracts and employment agreements. This increase in popularity reflects the state (and federal) policy that arbitration is a favored means of resolving dispute
admin
Nov 5, 20187 min read
Unlicensed Home Improvement Contractors Are Not Entitled To Payment Or To File Mechanics Liens
It is a good idea for homeowners to make sure that hired home improvement contractors are licensed. Licensure, however, is just as important from the perspective of the home improvement contractors because their rights and remedies could be impacted if they are not. New York case law and statutory law address this issue. In Millington v. Rapoport , 98 A.D.2d 765 (2 nd Dep’t 1983), in reversing the court below and dismissing plaintiff’s complaint which sought to foreclose
admin
Nov 2, 20185 min read
Despite Successful Enforcement Proceedings, Many Believe the SEC and CFTC Whistleblower Programs Need Improvement
Recently, this Blog wrote about the success of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission’s (“CFTC”) Whistleblower Program ( here ). As noted in that post, over the course of a few weeks, the CFTC had paid whistleblowers more than $45 million in awards. (The CFTC press release announcing the award can be found here .) Despite the positive direction in which the CFTC Whistleblower Program has been moving, many believe the whistleblower programs run by the CFTC and the Securiti
admin
Oct 31, 20183 min read
SEC Reaches Settlements with Defunct Dewey & LeBoeuf Executives
Last month, former Dewey & LeBoeuf, LLP (“Dewey”) executives agreed to a settlement with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC” or the “Commission”) to pay civil penalties in connection with their roles in a $150 million fraudulent bond offering by the now defunct international law firm. The SEC claimed that the executives used accounting tricks when the firm needed money to weather the economic recession and steep costs resulting from the merger between the pred
admin
Oct 29, 20183 min read
Using Real Property Law §329 To Cancel Certain Recorded Instruments
In the prior Blog article GET RID OF A STALE MORTGAGE BY BRINGING AN ACTION UNDER RPAPL 1501(4) , we discussed provisions of New York’s Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law that permit a mortgagor to remove, of record, the lien of a stale mortgage on real property. New York’s Real Property Law contain a similar provision that permits the court to cancel certain recorded instruments that are clouds on title but were not recordable or were not required to be recorded. Th
admin
Oct 26, 20183 min read
Courts Holds, as a Matter of Public Policy, Pre-Filing Release of Claims Does Not Bar Suit Under the False Claims Act
In today’s business environment, it is not uncommon for departing employees to sign a separation or severance agreement that includes a bar from bringing “any and all” claims related to their employment. The enforceability of such pre-filing releases has frequently been the basis for motions to dismiss by defendant companies in actions arising under the False Claims Act (“FCA”). The FCA is silent on the issue. Last month, a district court judge sitting in the United States D
admin
Oct 24, 20186 min read
First Department Holds That Arbitration Provision in Later-Signed Form U-4 Supersedes Dispute Resolution Provision in Earlier-Signed Employment Agreement
In March, this Blog wrote ( here ) about Hyuncheol Hwang v. Mirae Asset Sec. (USA) Inc. , 2018 N.Y. Slip Op. 30368(U) ( here ). Hwang involved an employment dispute in which Hyuncheol Hwang (“Hwang”) sought to stay the arbitration of his claims on the grounds that his employment agreement with Mirae Asset Securities (USA) Inc. (“Mirae”), a broker-dealer firm registered with FINRA, contained a forum selection clause directing the parties to litigate their disputes under the a
admin
Oct 22, 20183 min read
The Court Will Not Grant You Your Relief When First You Practice To Deceive
Sir Walter Scott’s original line is infinitely better (“O, what a tangled web we weave when first we practise to deceive!”) than this Blog title, which, nonetheless helps to illustrate the instant topic – Courts will not assist litigants in enforcing illegal contracts. Stone v. Freeman , 298 N.Y. 268 (1948), is a case involving commissions for the sale of clothing. The Stone plaintiff was a broker who sued for “his commissions earned in arranging a sale by defendant, who
admin
Oct 19, 20183 min read
Contribution and Indemnity: Court Rejects Claims for Both
The distinction between common-law indemnification and contribution is important, though its application is often difficult to navigate. Glaser v. Fortunoff , 71 N.Y.2d 643, 646 (1988) (noting, “the distinction is … critical,” although “the proper characterization of third-party claims … often cause confusion.”). Generally speaking, indemnity and contribution sort out the degree of culpability of multiple defendants and their responsibility for the payment of damages to th
admin
Oct 15, 20185 min read
New York County Commercial Division Holds That Only Fraud Claims Collateral To Contract Claims Can Survive A Motion To Dismiss
Courts do not hesitate to dismiss fraud claims when they are merely contract claims “dressed in the garb of a fraud count.” Songbird Jet Ltd., Inc. v. Amax Inc. , 581 F. Supp. 912, 924 (S.D.N.Y. 1984). “It is well settled that a cause of action for fraud does not arise, where the only fraud alleged relates to a contracting party’s alleged intent to breach a contractual obligation.” ( Caniglia v. Chicago Tribune-New York News Syndicate Inc., 204 A.D.2d 233, 34 (1 st Dep’t
admin
Oct 12, 20184 min read
Derivative Standing and Personal Animus: How Much Acrimony is Enough?
A shareholder’s derivative action is a lawsuit “brought in the right of a … corporation to procure a judgment in its favor, by a holder of shares or of voting trust certificates of the corporation or of a beneficial interest in such shares or certificates.” Marx v. Akers , 88 N.Y.2d 189, 193 (1996) (quoting Business Corporation Law § 626 (a)). Derivative claims against corporate officers and directors belong to the corporation itself. Auerbach v. Bennett , 47 N.Y.2d 619, 631
admin
Oct 10, 20183 min read
SEC Enforcement News: Elon Musk, Retail Brokers and Investment Advisors
The Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC” or “Commission”) ended the Government’s fiscal year with a flurry of proceedings and settled actions. In addition to the settled actions against Tesla Inc. and Elon Musk, the SEC filed or settled matters against retail brokers and investment advisors for violations of the securities laws and the rules promulgated thereunder. In today’s post, this Blog looks at some of these actions. Disclosure violations : On September 29, 2018
admin
Oct 8, 201810 min read


Get Rid Of A Stale Mortgage By Bringing An Action Under RPAPL 1501(4)
Typically, a mortgage on real property is delivered to stand as security for the repayment of an obligation evidenced by a promissory note. A mortgage is an encumbrance on real property. If there is an opportunity to remove such an encumbrance, it makes sense to do so.

Jonathan Freiberger
Oct 5, 20184 min read
The Essence of a “Time of the Essence” Letter
The date on which parties to a real estate contract must close is frequently subject to litigation. Sometimes real estate contracts provide for a closing date that is “time of the essence” and, in such cases, the parties must close on that date or risk default. In the event that a buyer fails to close on a “time of the essence” closing date, he risks being declared in default by the seller and losing his down payment (and being a party to any related litigation that may res
admin
Sep 28, 20184 min read
Goldman Sachs Requests Arbitration of Whistleblower Retaliation Claims
Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (“Goldman Sachs” or the “Company”) is requesting that wrongful termination claims brought by a former executive alleging whistleblower retaliation by the Company should be heard in arbitration or dismissed all together. In early August, former Goldman Sachs executive, Chris Rollins (“Rollins”), brought suit against the Company, asserting that its leaders wrongfully blamed him for failures with the Company’s anti-money laundering procedures, ruined h
admin
Sep 26, 20182 min read
bottom of page
